If you’ve been grinding through MLB The Show 25 and feel like you’ve only scratched the surface of the trophy or achievement list, you’re not alone. Many players overlook some of the most rewarding in-game objectives because they’re buried under game modes or tied to lesser-known mechanics. To help you boost your completion rate and earn those elusive bragging rights, we’ve rounded up 23 hidden goals that unlock valuable achievements — and in some cases, even help you earn rewards faster.

1. Win a Game Using Only Bunt Hits

Sounds crazy, but small-ball tactics can secure a rare achievement in certain play modes. Practice in Play Now before trying it in Diamond Dynasty.

2. Hit for the Cycle in Road to the Show

This one’s tougher than it looks. You'll need a home run, triple, double, and single in one game with your RTTS player. Speed builds and zone hitting help a lot.

3. Complete All Moments for One Program

Moments are often skipped by players in favor of faster XP routes, but completing an entire set tied to a program will pop an achievement — and might reward you with bonus packs.

4. Strike Out 15 Batters in a Ranked Match

Hard to pull off unless you’ve fully upgraded your pitcher loadout. This is also one of those achievements that pairs well with high-K veterans like Nolan Ryan.

5. Earn Parallel 5 on a Bronze Player

It’s not just about superstars. Leveling a low-tier card all the way to Parallel 5 proves dedication and nets you a hidden reward.

6. Walk Off a Game with a Sac Fly

Not glamorous, but clutch. This is a situational goal, so keep an eye on opportunities in late innings with runners on third.

7. Win a Franchise Game with Only Minor League Call-Ups

This hidden challenge taps into team management. Load your MLB roster with fresh call-ups and snag a win — not easy, but satisfying.

8. Score 10+ Runs in a Game Without a Home Run

You’ll have to string together doubles, steals, and heads-up base running. It’s a great way to test your non-power hitters.

9. Play All Star Missions with Theme Teams

Building full squads around themes (e.g. 1980s players, NL West teams) unlocks achievement milestones that aren’t clearly advertised.

10. Turn 3 Double Plays in One Game

Easier said than done. Use pitchers with sinkers or two-seamers, and set your defense to aggressive shifts.

11. Hit a Grand Slam with a Pitcher

Yes, it can be done — and it’s one of the rarest achievements in MLB The Show 25.

12. Win a Ranked Season Game in Extra Innings

These matchups are intense, and closing out in extras without quitting is something the devs recognize with a trophy.

13. Finish a Full Conquest Map in One Session

Requires stamina and strategy. Save time by pre-plotting your moves and quick-managing your games when possible.

14. Steal Home in a Live Game

Incredibly risky, but if you manage to swipe home — especially in a live competition — an achievement will flash immediately.

15. Win 10 Battle Royale Games Without Losing

This is a big ask, but if you can draft smart and play clean, you'll unlock multiple rewards in one streak.

16. Hit 3 Consecutive Home Runs in a Single Inning

Whether in Diamond Dynasty or Franchise, this feat is a power statement and ties into a hidden slugging challenge.

17. Record 20 Strikeouts with One Pitcher

Try this one in March to October on the right difficulty. You’ll need stamina and pinpoint control.

18. Throw a No-Hitter in Co-Op

Coordination and patience are key. This is one of the newer hidden achievements added in MLB The Show 25’s expanded co-op mode.

19. Hit a Walk-Off in a Moonshot Event

These events are pure offense, so keep swinging for the fences with power hitters and time your swing right.

20. Finish All Mini Seasons with the Same Core Squad

Consistency is rewarded here. Build a well-balanced team early and stick with it across seasons to unlock a hidden reward set.

21. Earn a Monthly Award Card from Scratch

Grind through the program missions instead of buying the card outright. The game tracks this path differently and grants you an extra achievement.

22. Create a Custom Stadium with 5,000+ Fans

Creative players get recognition, too. Use Stadium Creator to build a venue that hits the mark, and share it online.

23. Trade a Common Card for a Diamond in the Market

This won’t happen often, but savvy flipping using mlb the show 25 stubs can lead to surprisingly profitable exchanges.

Final Tips for Completionists

If you’re serious about chasing all 23 of these hidden goals, make sure your inventory and stub management is sharp. Sometimes you'll need to buy MLB The Show 25 stubs to acquire certain cards or complete programs faster. While there are always MLB The Show 25 stubs for sale on marketplaces, it’s important to compare prices and ensure you're getting fair value.

Sites like U4N are commonly mentioned in the community as reliable sources for in-game currency, but always approach any external transaction with caution and prioritize your account security.

Unlocking every hidden achievement won’t happen overnight — but with these goals in mind, you'll have a clear edge over casual players. Good luck grinding.