Only three players were awarded a 99 overall rating in MLB The Show 25, placing them firmly at the top of the game's talent hierarchy. Those players Buy mlb 25 stubsare Shohei Ohtani, Juan Soto, and Aaron Judge—each representing a unique style of dominance that transforms how they perform on the virtual diamond.

Shohei Ohtani of the Dodgers is first among equals with his elite dual-role capability. As a pitcher, he delivers top-tier velocity, sharp breaking pitches, and excellent stamina. At the plate, he couples 99 power with superb contact, especially against right-handed pitching. In The Show, Ohtani is the only player who can seamlessly shift between rotation and batting lineup, giving roster flexibility few others can match.

Juan Soto’s inclusion in the 99 overall tier highlights mastery of plate discipline. The Mets outfielder is rated 99 in discipline and clutch—the perfect combination of patience and timely delivery. His ability to work deep counts and punish mistakes makes him an on-base machine. This makes Soto one of the most feared hitters in the game, able to tilt the strike zone and force high-leverage mistakes from pitchers.

Aaron Judge, the Yankees’ slugging icon, rounds out the trio with unmatched power. Rated 99 in power against both right- and left-handed pitchers, Judge delivers consistency in launching home runs and extra-base hits. His contact ratings are slightly lower, but his ability to connect with immense force ensures that each swing carries major impact. For players focused on run generation and explosive offense, Judge is a go-to weapon.

In practical play, choosing between these titans depends on strategy. Ohtani offers unmatched flexibility—whether building a starting rotation or designing DH-centric lineups, he adds unmatched depth. Soto is ideal for high-OBP lineups and late-inning communication; he doesn’t need to hit bombs, but sets the table and wins games through discipline. Judge, meanwhile, is perfect for pure slugging lineups and power-hitters leagues, capable of changing the outcome with one swing.

Their impact extends beyond individual performance. In modes like MyTeam, the scarcity of 99-rated players elevates their value, making them cornerstone cards in any competitive deck. In Franchise mode, their elite ratings amplify performance metrics in runs, wins, and awards. Even in Road to the Show and Play Now, facing a team built around one of them raises the difficulty curve significantly.

Though only three players reach the 99 pinnacle, the next tier includes several 96 and 95-rated stars such as Ketel Marte, Mike Trout, Bobby Witt Jr., Mookie Betts, and Jose Ramirez. These players offer high-level performance too, but lack the exceptional ceiling that comes with the 99 rating tier. This gap reinforces the prestige and allure of Judge, Soto, and Ohtani.

Ultimately, MLB The Show 25 positions Ohtani, Soto, and Judge not just as game assets, but as modern legends. They reflect different but complementary forms of baseball excellence—Ohtani’s groundbreaking two-way talent, Soto’s unwavering discipline, and Judge’s brute force. For players aiming to build a dynasty, owning even one of them represents a game-changing advantage.